Minthara and halsin in party I successfully recruited Minthara using the updated Patch 5 knock-out method and she’s been in my party since I rescued her from Moonrise. upvotes Siding with Minthara. Yoiu can save Halsin and side with the tieflings in the immediate sense and still side with Minthara later, yes. The issue is the situation of the Tieflings as their default state in that case is that they are dead. To get her to join, you must help We would like to show you a description here but the site won’t allow us. Was hoping to just have as many party members as possible aside from Halsin - I know this is a choice between him and the drow But Dammon is dead. That way you could rescue Halsin and still have her alive to show up--though probably furious with you for destroying her plans. Like a proper rival. Then Minthara bugged out and I had to kill her and resurrect her, then everything was fine. 2. i painted Minthara and Moonrise Tower! 2. There's no companions preventing you to recruit another. In a long term perspective, you can Halsin or Minthara. I personally got Halsin recruited to my party (so did his portal request), and added him to my party. Just don't like em. 6) You progress the quest from Halsin until he offers to become permanent companion. If you're playing an evil character you probably don't want Wyll, Karlach and Halsin in your party. He will travel to the inn. Are Halsin and Minthara still clipping through each other at camp? Yes. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • Glass The original plan was that you could only have Minthara or Halsin, not both; that particular tent is where either one would camp depending on whether you raided the grove or killed the goblin leaders. Halsin and all the tieflings randomly died in pretty sure he means how did you get all the companions without them randomly quitting the party? siding with minthara alone nromally makes will, karlach and halsin instantly abandon you. Recruiting Minthara comes with consequences, including the inability to recruit Halsin and the risk of other companions leaving the party. Remember, Halsin is in to threesomes and foursomes. I am over 70hrs into the game and I find this out. So i went back and killed every goblin in Minthara's squad, and then knock her out. I feel like he would at least tolerate her until then but not be particularly happy about it. However someone told me in a FB group they were able to recruit both Minthara and Halsin through their play through by following certain tasks. 5) You save Minthara and she joins your party. Normally, you get Minthara before you complete that quest since you normally get to the tower before completing it. For Minthara you'd have to do the sheep glitch or if you're on pc, get the mod. Here are my ideas: Tav, Minthara, Halsin, and Gale or Tav, Karlach, Halsin, and Gale. But now that you can have both Halsin and Minthara, I had the thought: Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. You can still recruit and have Halsin in your party. Gather your party and venture forth! About Halsin and Minthara. I Hope Mintharas good Run recruitment gets more Improvements with Patch 7. The urge to just start all over to have every companion in my playthrough is driving me mad. Because Halsin is not a party member until you finish that quest. 2) Then they fixed the issue with Minthara and Halsin sharing the same tent in camp (they gave it to Minthara). I just plain and simple don't like druids. There is one method: You must steal an item in front of her at the goblin camp, this will make her temporarily hostile, then you must defeat her and knock her out. She was the sole survivor of the camp in the end. 4 - Go to the prison and free minthara (no need to save the halfings/gnomes yet) and fight your way out of moonlight tower (around the kitchen counter clockwise from the balcony is the safest way). Gale will too if his opnion is low and you fail his checks. The Grove will be decimated (along with the shopkeeper), Halsin will be unavailable and the Shadow Curse cannot be lifted. As before don't fight against Minthara is the requirement. 3) Now apparently (I haven't tried it yet in Patch 7) added some acknowledgement of the knockout to Minthara's dialogue. Zelvor will offer you the Crown (among other goodies) for your efforts. . 6 - Save halflings, save zevlor and finish the act. According to a reddit post from yesterday, in order to have Karlach and Wyll in the same party as Minthara is you have to completely ignore the attack the grove quest. He is being a hypocrite making exceptions for a Vampire Spawn, a Sharran, a warlock, and a mage with an explosive in his chest. Since patch 5, you can recruit Minthara as your companion and even a romance interest on a good playthrough without killing Tieflings and Druids in Emerald Grove. Once you’re in Act 2, you can do the recruiting quests for both Minthara and Halsin like normal. Well beside Halsin/Minthara that are mutually exclusive, unless you find a very twisted and not intended way. As the title states: I was bummed to learn that you cannot recruit Minthara unless you essentially turn on the tieflings, and in turn lose a bunch of other party members. SPOILER. So no idea, sorry. Next playthrough, i am definitely recruiting Minthara. I have two potential parties depending on if I recruit Minthara or not. And the twist about her ex being Sauron was incredibly epic. And I rescued Szazz, which I had forgotten. Passing this persuasion check will Halsin does not want to take that chance with Minthara, but can be a total hypocrite taking chances with the existing party. Minthara’s dialogue you can ask her about all companions and there is no option for Halsin. It was only due to the players wanting to experience both Halsin and Minthara in the party simultaneously that Larian Stuidos folded and updated the game to make it possible. Be warned that Minthara can be buggy no matter what, especially if you recruit her through the non-normal method (knocking her out vs siding with her against the Grove). You can share your reviews, ask questions and just be a part of this good community. Like Halsin gets His own tent in Camp or a bed in Elf Song Tavern. Ignore the Goblin Leaders. My issue is I had Halsin stay with me and he aggros everyone in his bear form. Met Halsin in the Alpha, so I somewhat know what he's like. But I was expecting a bit more from Halsin. And that Minthara has a few Dialogs for Halsin and the KO Thing. Halsin makes no mention of her after you recruit her. He wants me to kill Minthara but im playing as a drow and would like to recruit her to see our interactions. Minthara can be saved and recruited to the party. Im doing a neutral playtrough and just freed Halsin. Now i am in the mission to kill the goblin leaders. However Minthara is very bugged, and even though she has lines acknowledging Wyll and Karlach they also have some lines referencing her which you can't normally hear. Minthara brings versatility as a Drow Paladin and has humorous dialogue moments, making her an interesting addition to an evil playthrough in Baldur's Gate 3 . It depends on how you deal with Minthara. I just found out that you can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. Sneak her out of the tower from one of the hidden various exits within the Have Zrell show compassion for Minthara and she gets sent to the prisons. I was curious if they were ever set up to have any interactions with Recruiting Minthara & Halsin. In the game's current version, players can keep both companions by knocking out Minthara in the goblin camp instead of killing her, and then continuing with Halsin's questline. It is possible, im in a run with both right now 1-dont trigger the "kill goblin leaders" mission, 2-knock down minthara and kill the other two leaders, 3-dont save Sazza the goblin, dont worry for not triggering the mission, you will save the tieflins and rescue Halsin just the same. You can have both Minthara and Halsin in your party. Be aware tho that if you manage to get Halsin and Minthara, the latter won't have a tent at camp as they both use the same spot. If this is true, I question if this is I betrayed Minthara at the grove and fought her there and it felt so epic. Right before the fight with Oliver, Halsin offered to join my party, which I agreed to. Minthara to me is at minimum is perfectly fine with being evil when it suits her needs from what we've seen of her, and nothing about her redemption indicates otherwise that I've seen of it. From what others have said Halsin should have left, but now they share a tent :/. I'm afraid that this means they're not supposed to be on the party at the same time, I'm really hoping that Larian will fix this soon but in a way I can keep both of them. Here’s how to rescue Minthara and put her on your team without slaughtering innocents or making half of your party leave permanently. No need to go with her plan at all. Minthara is currently at the Goblin Camp chilling. I decided to look around in camp and I found Halsin just standing at a spot completely alone without a tent or anything, he still acts accordingly to the plot ( Minthara acts normal as well). Halsin won’t join your party afaik. Not sure if they will change tent locations or implement the datamined ultimatum where you have to choose between Halsin and Minthara. In act 2, I freed Minthara and helped Halsin remove the curse. Levelled her up, and good to go. She can also be romanced. If I knock her out in this scenario will she be available at Moonrise or no because she was aggros by Halsin's presence? Gather your party and venture forth! [SPOILERS] i read somewhere that larian did not intend for players to have both minthara and halsin, didnt know this and i randomly received backpacks and at the time didnt question it (idk why man) and im now realising it tl;dr: Yes it is possible to recruit Minthara in patch 5 without killing the tieflings in act one. Turn on non-lethal and knock her out (final blow can’t be magic or an arrow). If you're playing an edit 3: came back for another playthrough, wanted to check if patch had stopped minthara and halsin from being together. Minthara was looking to destroy the grove - Halsin's grove - and Halsin was a prisoner there trying to protect his people. My previous What I remember doing was: Rescued Halsin from his cell and talked to him, went into act 2 without triggering the raid, rescued Minthara and added her to my party without long resting, traveled back to act 1, long rested, and Halsin showed up in camp. Two commanders with an army fighting to the death. Just hanging around the main hall. Also, BTW, although it came as a surprise to me - people were expecting a confrontation - nah, Halsin gained inspiration when Minthara joined the party. But I was really disappointed that her and Halsin's campings location were overlooked: they both occupy the same spot, so their tents are one over the other. I knocked her out at the Goblin Camp and proceeded through Acts 1 and 2 as usual- saved the Grove and the Tieflings, helped Halsin find Thaniel, and recruited him to my party. And there you go, that's how you can bug the game enough to keep all of your party members and also chase the drussy. You will need a cheat (cheatengine, just search for it and minthara to Saving Halsin & Minthara Origin Characters I have free sazza the goblin and halsin from the cage. In my play though I saved her in moonrise and let her join the party. Halsin was at the party, enjoying the "stimulating company" of goblins and especially happy not to be in charge of the grove anymore . Talked to her, she instantly joined my party. Minthara was willing to work within the extremely fucked society that is Menzoberranzan because her family was in charge. So in a pre-Patch 5/unmodded playthrough, you could simultaneously romance either Astarion or Shadowheart alongside Halsin or Minthara (whichever you recruited). comments. In this case, you refuse to kill the three goblin leaders and progress to Act 2 without resolving the conflict. ) Then in act 2 you can save/recruit Minthara. If you side with Minthara and slaughter all the Tieflings, you can romance her and wake up the following day in a sequence that requires you to pass a persuasion check. So I reloaded my save and convinced Halsin that I'm only interested in him and my other relationship is over, no need to talk to anyone. So I knocked Minthara out in Act 1 and rescued her at Moonrise. 7) done :-D or is it this one? Not 100% tested yet, but the following steps seem to work: Shadowheart and Astarion are the only polyamorous companions in the game and only with Halsin. Was told I could sheep her and carry her to Moonrise. To do so you must enable non-lethal attack and knock her out while doing the "kill the three leaders" quest for Zevlor/Halsin. I also like how this exchange does help to flesh out some small part of their characters, which both Minthara and Halsin do need. At least she didn't for me. So now that it's possible to recruit Halsin and Minthara both in a good run (save the Tieflings and knock out Minthara while she's temporaily hostile in Goblin camp, (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG ruleset. She will not talk to me, though. My bet is on the ultimatum, since the lines are already in the game. Went to prison, rescued Minthara. I have both of them on my current playthrough. If this was doable before, it is not now, as that is not a choice upon right- clicking. I've had this play out to where Halsin is chilling near a bunch of goblins, and I simultaneously have the option to think about Karlach and to sleep with Minthara. This is also very reminiscent of the first two games and other RPGs where companions refuse to work together, which is nice. I thought Minthara killed him or something but the fact that Thaniel stayed next to Minthara gave me an idea that my game is just bugged. They're getting along famously. I intend to keep Gale in my party, and I will likely swap Astarion for someone else. This is what you need to do to recruit Minthara and stay good . That means going to Last Light Inn and looking for Thaniel to recruit Halsin and going to Moonrise And in Act 2, Minthara and Haslin are both in camp at the same time and can be placed into a party on the most recent patch with no mods? I have a save file from before Patch 1, where I To add both of them to your party you have to save Halsin and make him wait for you in the prison, then recruit Minthara first and him later in Act 2. You will need to venture northward, back into the Shadow-Curse, and towards the Minthara is an optional (and evil) party member in Baldur’s Gate 3. But I heard Minthara is pretty barebones. If you're playing a good hero character you probably don't want Minthara, Astarion and Lae'zel in your party. I think this upsets Halsin so he disappears a lot and sometimes just pops up in random places in camp, Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. A community all about Baldur's Gate III, the role-playing video game by Larian Studios. Baldur's Gate III is based on a modified version of the Dungeons & Dragons 5th edition (D&D 5e) tabletop RPG Doing my second playthrough now (half-orc Cleric/Paladin of Selune romancing Shadowheart) and thought it would be fun to try recruiting Minthara. Halsin came back to the grove and everyone is happy but MINTHARA IS PERMANENTLY KNOCKED OUT! And I still can't move her unconscious body. If you have Halsin with you as well he'll refuse to travel with her, giving you an ultimatum that will force you to part ways with either him or her. They occupy the same tent in camp though (maybe because they were intended to Since the new patch or hot fix (not sure which one) you can save minthara without siding with the goblins in act one. I think it is still a bit bugged, Thaniel just hangs around with Minthara. However, in EA patch 9, there was a way to get Minthara and Halsin together (technically). In the current iteration of the game, players can shift their attacks to Witness Minthara's inquisition. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online • baggedBoneParcel. If you do this, free Halsin and kill both of the other Goblin leaders, you will have saved the Grove. r/BaldursGate3. Gather your party and venture forth! Way to recruit Halsin and Minthara, and save Sazza? comments. Enter the interrogation room and talk to the interrogators, then attack them. So the choice I have right now is, do the grove quest to keep Karlach and Wyll and possibly get a companion I'll most likely never use or not finish the quest to get Minthara. But not in the long run, no. Ensure Minthara is imprisoned and not executed. This guide explains how to recruit Minthara on a “Good Playthrough” in Baldur’s Gate 3 without killing Tieflings. She will heal your party during that fight. Even when back to Act 2 area but still gone. Reply reply Top 1% Rank by size . I looted the grove and went to the goblin party with her. Honestly I don't care about Halsin, if the choice was to kill Minthara or Halsin I would keep Minthara gamewise (to have all different classes, except monk, since I am sorc), but slaughtering the whole grove with tieflings and druids in it are not that appealing as slaughtering stupid goblins. I'm sure developing some ultimatum, or perhaps a more coherent way for both to The next day, I found Minthara in Zevlor's cave. The devs didn't even have to put any effort into writing the romance between them because it pretty much writes itself. Minthara is an optional (and evil) party member in Baldur’s Gate 3. The party can first meet Halsin during their trip to the Goblin Camp, However, siding with the goblins can unlock the companion Minthara, an alternate romance option in BG3. (Same for Karlach and Wyll, both will leave the party if you try to raid the grove with them) To get them both you have to side with the grove and kill the goblin leaders, but use non-lethal attacks to knock out minthara rather than killing her. Having both Halsin and Minthara share the same tent in camp looks quite wrong, both in terms of narrative and gameplay. More posts you may like Related Baldur's Gate Role-playing video game Gaming forward back. Find Minthara in the dungeon, enter her mind, rescue her and kill her captors. Obviously, Minthara doesn't know that Halsin exists at all and I couldn't talk to her about it. Also if you skip the Grove vs Goblin and go straight to act 2 and save minthara (if you don't want to get your hands dirty while also want to get minthara) Halsin will be found dead in the worg pen. BG3 is the third main game in the Baldur's Gate series. Then you return for Halsin and tell him about the sleeping guy. For that to work, you have to start one of their romances in Act 1 and then make sure to pick flirting dialogue with Halsin during the course of the game (explicitly flirt at the grove party and ask about his love life when getting to know him dialogue becomes available). Those who have played Baldur's Gate 3 since it was first released will likely remember that there was originally no way to recruit both Halsin and Minthara in the same playthrough. She was very happy and thankful. In Act II they share a tent because they’re not intended to both be there, but it’s possible. Knocking out Minthara in act 1 will make her show up in act 2 and you'll be able to recruit her. However, she must be "temporarily Since the last update it is now very possible to get both Halsin and Minthara in the party without doing some wonky exploit. With Halsin, I basically completed the Lift the Shadow Curse quest; the only thing left to do is kill Ketheric. To get her to join, you must Is it possible to get both as party members if I incapacitate Minthra when she attacks the Grove rather than killing her? Don't know if it matters but after she left to attack the Allow the player to have both Minthara and Halsin the party! I wish there was a way to spare Minthara's life during Act I while siding with the Tieflings/Druids instead of the goblins. After killing everyone but left Minthara knocked down, I went back and escaped with Halsin, Then I went to the Grove and turned his quest, got all the rewards, I even stole the Idol for Mol. Ideally I'd like to make it so the teiflings don't die on the road, but I understand that might not be possible with Minthara since Halsin is currently in my camp chilling. On my current playthrough (Durge), I was able to keep Wyll and Halsin and get Minthara no-problem by locking the grove, attempting to betray the grove to Minth, freeing Halsin, and then proceeding on to Act 2 (avoiding her at the grove). Since patch 5, you can recruit Minthara as your companion and After obtaining Minthara, decline to put her in the active party as many of the cultists will now have a grudge against the Drow Paladin. At least for me, it's always been that way, so it seems I really wanna test out Minthara, but not doing a chaotic evil run (more like neutral/chaotic good), so I helped the tieflings in the grove with Kagha situation, but never killed the goblin leaders. Because there's a whole vast of gray between 'moral, good pure hero' and 'murderhobo evil'. I plan to knock out minthara while kill all the goblins so she will be at the moonrise for be recruit. In turn they: I've just done the shadow portal bit with Halsin, and now I have both Minthara and Halsin with me, in camp they stand togetherweirdly. If you knock her out and kill the other 2 leaders, the grove is safe. I didn't need to steal or attack Minthara when I approached, she was already hostile because of Halsin. Please include the correct flair for your post: - New Pickup / Review - In Search Of - Collection - The exploit that became canon when the Larian team made it a little bit easier allows you to defeat Minthara by knocking her unconscious. You can 100% get Both Minthara and Halsin in your party without issue. If you rescue Halsin, he will force you to wipe out the goblin (that includes minthara, even though you already recruited her). Walnut stampede! Super_Yamcha 10 months ago #10. Minthara is not remotely like After that I just beat everyone up, and I rescued Halsin, but I told him to stay in the prison. I assume this is a bug and not meant to be possible? I've read that there is a supposed choice between them that Halsin is It would be really interesting if there was an option where you could avoid Minthara but still wipe out the goblins and save the grove. Went to towers. Easily done: go to goblin camp, slaughter everyone BUT when you fight Minthara make sure to toggle non lethal damage on JUST FOR HER, once she's knocked out, slaughter the rest of the goblins; now go to the prison and save Halsin, quest will progress normally, now when you get to the shadowcursed lands you can do whatevs, just make absolutely sure to go to Moonrise Gather your party and venture forth! Could someone share how to keep both Minthara and Halsin, I heard its doable now. But this should only be possible if you knocked her unconscious at the goblin camp. In the prison, kill the scrying eyes first using turn based mode, then the guards standing outside her interrogation room. Modding will be your friend if you want them both. It's impossible to recruit halsin if you raid the grove. If you do this, finish the rest of the goblin camp as normal, and you will find her in Act II at moonrise, and she is recruitable in Has lead to some awkward moments 😅 Minthara was sitting right there last night when Halsin propositioned my Tav, and presumably noticed when he snuck off later that night Fast-forward to this morning when she asks to read Tav’s thoughts, and I can only assume Tav and Halsin are exchanging glances over her shoulder knowing those thoughts are going to be full of a certain Now I'm playing a Tempest Cleric, with intentions to multiclass into Storm Sorceror at level 5. She’s a deadly Paladin that wields two blades at once and serves the Cult of the Absolute. Now it's possible to get both Halsin and Minthara in same party in Act 2 but leaks abd dataminer have allegedly found strings of code for camp dialogue scene that will forces you to choose between Halsin and Minthara in Act 2. Then Halsin comes along like a celebrity when he didnt contribute. You can get her in act 2 this way, and keep everyone except Halsin. Of course some specific story decisions might make them leave the party, but there's no decision in the game beside Halsin/Minthara that will result into making one leave or make leave another if not. Kept Halsin in my party, kicked another person out when we got to camp after rescuing her. This would really Help making her good Run recruitment better. Thanks to Reddit user u/DJay_lost for sharing this method. Thus you get Halsin in act 1 (sort of. Before that update, players were finding all sorts of methods to manipulate the game to include Minthara in the group. Minthara's sister Minratha and Karlach go together like peanut butter and jelly. Gather your party and venture forth! Members Online. I feel like the option of recruiting Minthara at Moonrise should come at the cost of losing Halsin post shadow curse plot. The other companions have acknowledged Minthara, but Halsins just keeps talking about the shadow curse. Although in Minthara’s case, that might be helped if her romance is fully fixed. But by far the most interesting thing is you’ll be able to recruit cunning Drow character Minthara without dispatching a whole grove of druids – a curious change on Larian’s part. Too bad you can't get Minthara, Minratha, AND Karlach in the same party though. She will appear in act 2 and you can get her to join your team. 5 - Go to camp and you'll see minthara and halsin, now you can recruit halsin to the team. Like I was expecting him to react to her, and maybe be a bit against her joining considering the whole grove At the beginning of act 3 Halsin told me that he'd like to bed me but that I needed to talk to my lover first. Patch 5 added a whole load of content on its own. She’s a deadly Paladin that wields two blades at once and serves the Cult of the Absolute. Gather your party and venture forth! Rescue halsin like normal, talk to Minthara but don’t get into a fight through dialogue. findings, you can have minthara and halsin together in camp until just before you enter the shadow lands, 2 In the one playthrough I recruited Minthara I let Halsin die in the Shadowfell portal. ADMIN MOD Minthara and Halsin in Patch 6 (no long rest?) Quest Help I've been planning a new good run to get Minthara and Halsin for a while now. Reply reply More replies More replies And If I try to make her leave by invading the grove, Halsin refuse to leave the goblin camp even with the grove under attack. Halsin and Minthara will likewise not acknowledge one another and their camps will overlap as they aren't supposed to be in the same party by default. I've cleared enough content to head to The Shadow-cursed lands. Any help would be appreciated on how to get them back sck. Halsin and Minthara disappeared from camp and party Origin Characters I was able to recruit both into party I’ve done but left to go back to Act 1 area and now neither are In party. mfcdz yloxe rtbzo egccx sydfg ntgxk npjl wgck llpckab fsvig