Scholarone manuscripts status under review reddit ' However, I'm A lack of novelty is one of the top reasons that Scientific Editors reject manuscripts without review. the employee of the publisher assigned to the journal) or the editor-in-chief assigns an editorial board member to handle the paper. When I asked about my status, the I have submitted a manuscript through the ScholarOne system. Select “Unsubmitted Manuscripts” to see your started manuscripts, click “Continue Submission” to complete your submission. Submission of a manuscript to one professional journal while that manuscript is under review by any other journal is regarded as unacceptable. I find it hard to find out which status is the current one as they are both displayed ? Shortly after, it was assigned an EO (one of the editors) and I get a message addressed from that person saying "Your manuscript has been successfully submitted online and is presently being given full consideration for publication". What does the manuscript status mean? The status of a manuscript helps editors quickly understand what work has been done reviewing the article. Also, ScholarOne keeps coming out with updates, once almost every two-three months, so status descriptors also keep changing. •You wish to recommend rejection without review. The peer review history package includes the complete editorial decision letter for each revision, with reviews, and your responses to reviewer comments, including attachments. However, it could also mean that it has progressed from the basic administration check to the associate editor I submitted a paper to a journal that uses the ScholarOne submission system. Does this mean that the Hello everybody, I have submitted my manuscript for over 2 months via scholarone. It is an automated data-base implemented over the internet for submission, review, decisioning and tracking of papers under review for Preprint your manuscript while it’s under review . 2024. guide is intended to give an overview of the Reviewer function in ScholarOne Manuscripts. Before submitting your review, ensure the following: All required fields (marked with red asterisks) have been completed. You must complete your review online using the features of an electronic manuscript management system “ScholarOne Manuscripts™” (S1M) which has individual pages for each IEEE I have been confused with the present status of my manuscript whose status follows the following timeline: Manuscript initially submitted through Editorial Manager (Springer): 25 Jan 2017; Under Review: 27 Feb 2017 till 9 Jun 2017; Reviews completed: 10 Jun 2017 till 22 Jun 2017; Editor assigned: 22 Jun 2017; The journal is in the field of Computer Science and If you have already started your manuscript, or the journal has sent it back so that you can make changes, it will be marked in blue on the “My Manuscripts” dashboard once you login to your Author Centre. I'm second author and submission is To check the status of your submission in our system, please follow the below instructions: Log into your ScholarOne Manuscripts account; Click on “Author” Under the Author Dashboard Section, click on “Submitted Manuscripts” Here, you will see the most recent status. This guide is intended to give an overview of the Reviewer function in ScholarOne Manuscripts. My manuscript submitted on a ScholarOne submission system was showing "Under review" for 1 month. 5 months, so I thought it was being reviewed by reviewers. The status “Under Review” indicates that the peer review process is ongoing, and could take up to 2-3 months to complete. After a week the status changed to “Under Review”. The ScholarOne platform seamlessly integrates ORCID in manuscript submission, editorial, and peer review workflows. A few days ago, the status changed from 'Awaiting reviewer response' to 'Awaiting reviewer scores. Thanks though. I am conscious that as a non academic, any willingness to engage I get from any scholar would be potentially limited- I don’t want to jump in too early and waste any potential Hello everybody, I have submitted my manuscript for over 2 months via scholarone. Hence the first Editor Assigned to Under Review. This status "With Associate Editor" means that the associate editor who is in charge of your manuscript has received the minimum number of reviews (usually 2) for your paper. It means its under review. Therefore, the Assigned Editor (AE) has now sent the manuscript back for peer review with a new set of reviewers. So, in this r/BritishColumbia is dedicated to all things related to the Canadian province of British Columbia, situated on the stunning West Coast. If you get a manuscript you think is trash, you write the review on the manuscript. This ScholarOne Manuscripts™ web site has been optimized for Microsoft© Internet Explorer 8. To begin, log in with your user ID and password. Please see below for the manuscript status definitions. Now, this status has remained for 18 days. The steps below are the high-level steps in the review process. After two months, it changed to “awaiting recommendation” status. I submitted a revised manuscript, but the status has not been changed from “under consideration” for 1 month. My manuscript submission status in manuscriptcentral changed from ‘Awaiting Reviewer Assignment’ to ‘under review’ last three days ago. What does it mean? Manuscript status on ScholarOne is "ED: Not Assigned, EE:Name: Under Clarivate Analytics | ScholarOne Manuscripts™ Reviewer User Guide Page 1 Effective Date: 21-January-2019 Document Version: 2. However, manuscript statuses can be different for different journals. But today suddenly the status changed back to I recently submitted a manuscript to a journal using the ScholarOne submission system. Then it said “Awaiting Recommendation” for 2 weeks, and now as of a week and half it says “Awaiting As mentioned above, ‘Under Review’ could mean that your manuscript has been sent for a peer review. Additionally, ScholarOne keeps making updates through ScholarOne Manuscripts. Welcome to the submission site for Basic & Clinical Pharmacology & Toxicology. What Under Review: This means that the manuscript is presently under peer review. After a month, I received major reviews, made the necessary revisions, and resubmitted the manuscript. Thank you for agreeing to review manuscripts for the IEEE Sensors Journal. I recycle all of my cover letters. Another time my status said after 2 weeks from the interview: your activity submission in progress. New figure screening policy The status of one of my manuscripts on ScholarOne is "ED: Not Assigned, EE: Rodríguez-Vázquez, Angel , Under Review". All comments directed to the author are located under ‘Comments to the Author’ and all confidential comments to the editor are located under ‘Confidential Comments to the Editor. Previously I've seen 'under review', etc, which I found logical, but this status is unclear to me (the status was updated over a week ago). The reason with it is now Editor Assigned can be due to several reasons. Now it is showing "Awaiting decision" What does it mean? Any chance of acceptance? "Under review" was the first status that showed up directly after submission. After one day of submission, status was ‘Awaiting Decision’; but now after 10 days, status change into ‘Awaiting reviewer selection’. Under Consideration The “Under Consideration” status means that your application has passed the initial review and Yes, but the question is under review by whom. From local news and events to breathtaking scenery and outdoor activities, this community is a hub for British Columbians and anyone interested in This is a list indicating your manuscripts status. Although an ADM has been assigned, the 'Under Review' status seems to get stuck for almost 2 months. 29 June 2024. #2. If that is the case, it probably refers to the internal editorial review (also The manuscript status has changed from "Under Review" to "Awaiting Reviewer Scores". Please read the guide for ScholarOne authors before making a submission. 1 2 3 The status reviews completed was for one week and then it changed to with editor again for last 10 days. Stages of Peer Review Stages of Peer Review from Submission to Accept/Reject Decision. This depends a lot on the manuscript management system, and the editorial practices. • Receive invitation to review • Accept invitation • Review manuscript • Complete review online Your paper is resubmitted. I just submitted a revised paper to ScholarOne (major revision). That reduces the hostility in the tone of the review. In the editorial manager I can see the status of the manuscript. The Review Process The steps below are the high-level steps in the review process. I submitted a manuscript to journal A at the beginning of February and its status on ScholarOne is currently "under review". To continue the submission for manuscripts you already created. Supporting over 365 societies and publishers, over 3,400 books and journals, and 13 million users, ScholarOne is the industry leader. Now, the Under Review status typically means that the manuscript has been sent for peer review. I'm sure it was sent out for peer-review as I have sent an inquiry to the editor. It is a no-cost opportunity to display some collegiality. Don't mean to be mean, but you are probably overthinking this. (Note that for some journals, this could mean the AE review, but again, here, it does seem that the manuscript is being checked by the peer However, the status of my revised manuscript is showing "awaiting reviewer scores" again. On the right of the bar is the Processing Status. So, ScholarOne may work differently for different journals. instead of moving to "Under Review", the status changed to "Awaiting AE Recommendation When the reviewers accept to review your manuscript, the status will change to under review. e. For instance, ‘RM’ seems to be a new status indicator. But today suddenly the status changed back to Since the status is EA: Name of Editor "Under Review”, it seems like the paper is still being screened by the journal and has not yet been sent to peer reviewers. Thanks ahead!!! It is common for the peer review status of a manuscript to change several times before a final decision is reached by the editor. There is no need for anonymising the manuscript upon guide is intended to give an overview of the Reviewer function in ScholarOne Manuscripts. :-) Incidentally, we wonder what would have happened with the earlier submission, although it was a while ago. This work describes much-needed research into whatever important topic and is timely because of whatever. On my primary app and all previous secondaries, I simply listed this paper as "Manuscript Under Review". Under Review: This status means that the manuscript is under peer review. Contributions to the Transactions, Journals, and Letters may be submitted electronically on IEEE's on-line manuscript submission and peer-review system, ScholarOne® Manuscripts (former Manuscript Central). On ScholarOne Manuscri. Now, it shows Awaiting Decision. I submitted a manuscript on ScholarOne submission system. In other words, it doesn't say "under review" unless a reviewer has been invited. So, these multiple statuses (which although seem to be around the same status of reviewer selection) are a reflection of the workflow at this particular journal. As of Under Review: This means that the manuscript is presently under peer review. The authors aren't central to the review, the manuscript is. The Under Review status: No Reviewers Invited - An article has been submitted, but no reviewers have been invited. But today suddenly the status changed back to My manuscript submission status in manuscriptcentral changed from ‘Awaiting Reviewer Assignment’ to ‘under review’ last three days ago. The manuscript status has changed from "awaiting reviewer scores" back to "under review". Two months after the inquiry, the status is showing "Under Review" and below it there is "Evaluating Recommendation". Depending on the particulars of how the journal operates and how much of the review process it makes visible, this is likely to mean one of two things with respect to the standard journal workflow:. Either the desk editor (i. Whatever I do, I really want to give my theory the best shot. I'm in the field of nutrition research as a 3d year PhD candidate. The Progress box provides a snapshot of the review status. When not considered/ picked I noticed the app will always say under consideration for review before I get a reject letter. Under ‘Account Information’, scroll to ‘Send a This is the initial status that your application will have when you submit it. Fingers crossed 🤞, we got an email from them stating "We thank you for your submission and acknowledge the delay in responding with a decision. To update you, two reviews have been returned. • Receive invitation to review • Accept invitation • Review manuscript • Complete review online The status "Under review" is ambiguous- it could be an internal review or a peer-review. When I applied other positions, they all appeared under consideration. Authors can now opt to preprint their manuscript during the submission process and ScholarOne: EDITOR Quick Guide – How to perform in S1 Version 1. Firstly, ‘EO’ stands for Editorial Office. Most likely, the journal simply Submitting Papers in ScholarOne Manuscripts Introduction ScholarOne Manuscripts (S1M) is the peer review management tool used by IEEE. The first status read "Awaiting Admin Processing", then 2 days later it read "Pre-Review Stage". THE REVIEW PROCESS . How can I determine the status of my manuscript? A17: When you log into ScholarOne and access your Author Center you will see a status bar with the title of all manuscripts you’ve submitted to ScholarOne. Per your agreement with the Associate Editor, you should complete the review within two weeks. ’ Your review follows COPE guidelines. Did the AE send the paper to more referees? Or/and he/she will also make a review for the paper? Or it is something else? This guide is intended to give an overview of the Reviewer function in ScholarOne Manuscripts. Now for another position it says: My status: activity submission is being evaluated. Can anybody give some advice? Is my manuscript for I submitted a paper to a journal that uses the ScholarOne submission system. At the first submission, the status has been updated at each step (ex. I did not receive any emails After 3 months with an "Awaiting Referee Report" status in a ScholarOne Manuscripts journal, the new status changed to "Awaiting AE decision" and in the same day back to "Awaiting Referee Report". •You receive two reviews with conflicting recommendations. “with referees”), so I’m worried about the unchanged status of this resubmission. The field of interest is in Earth Sciences. With a typical ScholarOne configuration, "Awaiting Reviewer Scores" means that it is actually out with (at least some) reviewers, while "Under Review" would instead mean the previous stage, where it is being considered by the handling editor(s) and might My first PhD research paper is under the status "pending decision". Is this common in scientific journals? I submitted others manuscripts to other journals and the review process was different. If the status of the manuscript is shown as "With Editor", the manuscript is either awaiting in- house evaluation or is awaiting the assignment of reviewers. If the reviewers are slow and the journal doesn't have a policy mandating reviewers to submit the Q17. Earlier it was pending recommendation. " The manuscript status was changing back to “Under Review” perhaps due to one of following reasons: Some of the reviewers that initially accepted to review the manuscript have now declined to review it due to their unavailability. This status can last anywhere from a few days to several weeks. o AUTHOR-SUPPLIED DATA: ‘Show’ at Custom Questions to access declarations, ‘agreed’ status only). Two months after the inquiry, the I submitted a manuscript to a journal about a week ago (via ScholarOne). r/BestBuy is a community-driven subreddit for employees and customers to engage in meaningful conversations, ask for help, and discuss the company or their local store. • Receive invitation to review • Accept invitation • Review manuscript • Complete review online Reddit. For the first week of submission, the status was "with editor" and then it changed to under review for one week, then reviewers asigned So, these multiple statuses (which although seem to be around the same status of reviewer selection) are a reflection of the workflow at this particular journal. To open the draft/unsubmitted manuscript, click Unsubmitted and Manuscripts in Draft, and click Continue on the manuscript. I encourage all authors to add this important information to increase the likelihood that their manuscripts will be sent for peer review. Status shows "Revision submitted to journal". This document will Admin and Editor, are grouped together under a heading with a drop-down list. Most recent answer The paper is still in Under Review status. Peer review is an honorary service that requires detailed scrutiny and evaluation of the manuscript and therefore takes time. I had a final interview last Friday and then today I checked and the status is now at "Under Review". ScholarOne offers workflow solutions for the submission and review of manuscripts, abstracts, proceedings, books, grants & awards and production. The fact that the status changed from "Required Reviews Completed (There is indeed a well know journal about this author and their website says they accept manuscripts). IEEE Access has a typical acceptance rate of about 30%, which is As a founding member of ORCID, Clarivate Analytics shares this vision and has consistently worked to integrate the ORCID persistent identifier into solutions which support research and accelerate the lifecycle of innovation. Once the hiring manager reached out to me the status was changed to "Hidden". Meaning of double statuses on ScholarOne: Awaiting ME Decision and Awaiting CE/Reviewer Scores What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A guide to understanding journal statuses; The status of one of my manuscripts on ScholarOne is "ED: Not Assigned, GE: Not Assigned, Awaiting JM Checklist". Here the status could show "Editor assigned", or it could show "awaiting reviewer invitation". This menu is displayed wherever you are working in the system to allow you to easily move between functions. Last week, I submitted another manuscript to journal B also via The next day after the submission, the manuscript's status changed to 'Under Review'. . FIND OUT MORe SCHOLARONe MANUSCRIPTS A month ago, I submitted my paper to the Emerald journal, which uses the ScholarOne manuscript system. The phrase "peer review in process" is vague and could mean anything: for example, the manuscript could be with reviewers, or it could be on the editor's desk, or it could even be that the reviews are complete and it's just waiting for a decision from the editor. The status changed to "Under review" 4 months ago, but now it is still showing the same status. I'm relatively new to publishing and I get I'm probably overthinking this. Further, it is assumed that work submitted I had submitted a manuscript in Scholarone system. The dashboard status is showing that the paper is under review but the editor has given the decision on dated 25. But today suddenly the status changed back to A ScholarOne Manuscripts site is organized around Centers, each one a logical destination for peer review participants. I've submitted a manuscript to a journal. Could you please let me know what exactly does it mean? Was it sent for peer review, or is it just the editorial review? Took about 2 weeks to assign reviewers, then it was “Under Review” for about 9 weeks. I was rejected a day after. This does not mean that he has received all the reviews he is expecting, some reviewers are invited or accept their invitations later than others (sometimes 2-3 weeks apart, even longer), or maybe For the first week of submission, the status was "with editor" and then it changed to under review for one week, then reviewers asigned for the next two days then again changed to under review for I have a question about the status in ICIMS. • Receive invitation to review • Accept invitation • Review manuscript • Complete review online While this typically means that the manuscript is awaiting peer review, because the status changed so quickly after submission, this probably refers to the internal review, which is about aspects such as a match with the PLOS offers accepted authors the opportunity to publish the peer review history of their manuscript alongside the final article. The Journal of Survey Statistics and Methodology accepts submissions through ScholarOne Manuscripts, our online submission system. It was "Under Review" for 2. 2024 as mentioned below guide is intended to give an overview of the Reviewer function in ScholarOne Manuscripts. Can anybody give some advice? Is my manuscript for To check the status of your submission in our system, please follow the below instructions: Log into your ScholarOne Manuscripts account; Click on “Author” Under the Author Dashboard Section, click on “Submitted Manuscripts” Here, you will see the most recent status. The status changed to admin check to under review after one week. This manuscript has not been submitted elsewhere, and all studies described Have been reviewed and approved by the whatever institutional review board. What does it mean? What is the meaning of "decision in process" status? Does "Under Review" mean that the paper has passed the editorial check? What does the status 'under editor evaluation' mean? HANDBOOK: Keep calm and wait: A I finished my hirevue on Dec 2021. The amount of time a manuscript is in review depends on reviewer availability. I applied for a position and originally the status showed as "Under Review". Will the status change once the required number reviews is completed? 論文STATUS欄に表示される Editor (AE, EIC) や管理者(ADM) のハイパーリンクをクリックすると、Email 作成画面が立ち上がりますので、この画面から状況についてお問い合わせいただけます。 ScholarOne Manuscripts: 査読状況についての確認 We might be using different editorial management systems then - the system I'm most familiar with has statuses "submitted to journal", "editor assigned", and then only "under review". I suppose that in most cases of minor revision, the revised manuscript will only be reviewed by the ADM or associate editor. Does anyone know about what’s going on. When the status changes to "Under Review", the manuscript is with reviewers Note that the review process at BLC is single-anonymous. This document will describe each of these steps in detail. 0 and Chrome 24. However, "Evaluating recommendation" is usually the status when the manuscript has been peer-reviewed and the reviewer comments are being evaluated by the journal administration to determine whether the article should be accepted (with or without changes Under Review: This status means that the manuscript is under peer review. Two days ago, status of my manuscript changed from awaiting refree scores to awaiting AE decision but now again it has changed to awaiting refree SETTING THE NUMBER OF REQUIRED REVIEWS Common reasons to change the number: •More than two of the invited reviewers agree to review. 7 INTRODUCTION As a Reviewer of a manuscript, your input is a crucial part of the peer review process. Complete guidelines for preparing and submitting your manuscript to this journal are provided below. IEEE Access strives to maintain an expedited peer review process of only 4 to 6 weeks, however, all article submissions still undergo a thorough peer review process to ensure only high-quality articles are published. Hi good day, I have submitted my article in energies (energies-3092655) on dated 21. THE REVIEW PROCESS If however, the paper has been showing the status "Under review" from the time of submission, without any other status change, then it could mean that your paper is still under the initial admin check by the journal and has not yet been assigned to an Editor or reviewer. The status listed for it Hi Amal – welcome back to the forum! This question seems on similar lines to your earlier query, though the difference is that there, things moved to ‘Ready for Decision’ quite quickly, whereas here, they’ve moved slowly, but perhaps a bit more positively. From a purely grammatical perspective there’s not much difference between the two terms. The status shows that the Editorial Assistant (EA) has yet to complete the initial checks on the paper. However, after we made the revisions, the manuscript status changed to "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation. THE REVIEW PROCESS The steps below are the high-level steps in the review process. What does this “under consideration” mean? The first mission of the editor is to assign reviewers and take a decision depending on their return. Very anxious. I submitted my manuscript to a journal from 1 month ago in scholar one. (Note that for some journals, this could mean the AE review, but again, here, it does seem that the manuscript is being checked by the peer I have submitted a manuscript through the ScholarOne system. TII - Initial Submission Submission of a new manuscript for review. 1 (June 2016) View manuscript resubmissions = blue bar, invited manuscripts = yellow bar. This year, too few authors included a description of their unique perspective in their submission letters. The particular journal has an avg tie from submission to first decision 182 days. However, although the paper went under review on 6th September, the status date of the paper have changed several times Each publisher uses the ScholarOne system in their own way, making customizations to suit its workflow. This journal uses ScholarOne Manuscripts (previously Manuscript Central) to peer review manuscript submissions. However, I just noticed that the status of my When you submit a research manuscript for peer review, the journal may report the status of the review as “in review” or “under review”. 06. It's signed by the editorial office. It may be that one journal uses the term “in review” and another the term “under review”, both to signify the same thing: that your I submitted a manuscript to a SAGE journal through ScholarOne 4 months ago. ScholarOne Manuscripts accommodates all possible user role types in the peer review process including Authors, Editors-in-Chief, Associate Editors, Reviewers, Administrative Staff and Boards of Editors. After the second round of review, the editor provided some minor language revisions, and all three reviewers had no further comments. 0 and higher, Firefox 19, Safari 6. My application status is still under consideration It has been 6 months and I haven’t hear back from hirevue. Content. If the manuscript passes this check, it will then be assigned to a handling editor who will initiate the peer review process by assigning 2-3 potential reviewers to review the manuscript. Yesterday my lab heard back regarding a paper, with positive reviews and editor asking for some revisions. View Why the manuscript submission status changed from ‘Under review’ to ‘Awaiting Reviewer I resubmitted my manuscript to a journal through ScholarOne. The default number of reviewers is two. I have submitted my paper to one of the springer journal. I submitted a manuscript to a scientific journal. costs. Reviewers Invited - At least one reviewer has been invited to review the manuscript. This is why Antonin Scalia's death was such a great loss, who is left to tell people to just read the goddamn words. Beginning Fall 2019, Hydrological Processes is participating in a pilot of the under review service, Wiley’s new initiative to streamline the early sharing of research and open up the peer review process. Click each status to see your past performance in detail. What does this change mean? Does it mean that one of the selected reviewers has declined the invitation? Is it a bad sign? It isn't about active or passive, it's about what you center. A status of “Under review” means that your manuscript is being reviewed. If you are unsure about whether or not you have an account, or have forgotten your password, go to the Reset Password screen. yyg pbxqls moyqlj srbknx cgsn mpdk lwpna edzd ypm vxmje